Effects of Capital Controls on Foreign Exchange Liquidity

The literature on capital controls has focused on their use as tools to manage capital and improve macroeconomic and financial stability. However, there is a lack of analysis of their effect on FX market liquidity.... [ view full abstract ]

The literature on capital controls has focused on their use as tools to manage capital and improve macroeconomic and financial stability. However, there is a lack of analysis of their effect on FX market liquidity. Technological and regulatory changes in FX markets over the past decade have had an influence on the effect of controls on alternative indicators of FX liquidity. In this paper, we introduce a theoretical model showing that, if capital controls are modelled as entry costs, then fewer investors will enter an economy. This will reduce the market’s ability to accommodate large order flows without a significant change in the exchange rate (a market depth measure). On the other hand, if capital controls are modelled as transaction costs, they can reduce the effective spread (a cost-based measure). Using a panel of 20 emerging market economies and a novel measure of capital account restrictiveness, we provide empirical evidence showing that capital controls can reduce cost-based measures of FX market liquidity. The results imply that capital controls are effective in reducing the implicit cost component of FX liquidity but can also have a negative structural effect on the FX market by making it more vulnerable to order flow imbalances.